EIDLLA EW [DNA?] NROBLLA ERAEW
                        [Niemand’s translation:
                   We are all born and we all die]

(Nimmerwahr, 1868) Niemand’s suggested
emendation, as well as his translation based on it, will
plainly not do; among other things, the pure
uninterpretability of the text, which alone constitutes
its significance, is thereby beclouded.

(Schwartzweiss, 1869) Significance, indeed! “Sing
if”-icance, only an easy transposition away, puts
Nimmerwahr’s whole flimsy matter more accurately
… Mere lyrical hypothesis gets us nowhere.

(Nirgendswo, 1869) The text is quite clear, and if
seemingly “uninterpretable” (thus Nimmerwahr!),
only because it is merely so much a commonplace as
to be trivial. Niemand’s conjecture is, of course,
quite sound.

(Stillschweigend, 1870) Sound? Sound!!!??? A
ridiculous suggestion, all the more dangerous in that
it invites the ill-considered judgment to agree with
the reductively positive Schwartzweiss, who is, as
always, incapable of grasping crucial nuance.